Recently I
watched a programme on the BBC called Storyville:
The Cult That Stole Children. It was another one of those documentaries about
a cult leader - this time a delusional, narcissistic bint called Anne
Hamilton-Byrne - who led a brainwashing sect that left its members with all
sorts of scars and traumas in adulthood.
The maltreated
children of the sect were dressed in matching outfits, had identically dyed blonde
hair, were isolated from the outside world, and regularly beaten, starved and
injected with LSD under the leadership of this awful woman and her husband.
Whilst under
the thrall of Anne Hamilton-Byrne, the sect members exhibited something that is
generally true at a wider societal level - and that is that unless you can
extricate yourself from the proximity of the group, you are unlikely to change
your prejudice unless a large proportion of your group members do so likewise.
This
is because your group’s culture, ethos, tribal connectivity and goals are paramount
to its (and your) identity. Therefore your group is definitely on the right
side of the argument and all opponents are on the wrong side. Anybody that
wishes to undermine your group, even with evidence and good reasoning, is seen
as a threat to the group's structural integrity, and consequently will be
written off as a crank with which group members shouldn't identify or
associate.
This
wisdom has wider ramifications in other socio-political areas, because as long
as in-group tribalistic associations remain the driving force for many of the
extreme and absurd ideas people have, the likelihood of any individual in the
group seeing sense is lessened.
One of the great leaps forward that humanity still requires - hopefully to be aided by our modern day access to the entire world's knowledge - is the freeing up of the individual from the unhelpful collectives that taint and retard his or her thinking, and the bringing about of rational pursuits that stand or fall on their own empirical merits.
One of the great leaps forward that humanity still requires - hopefully to be aided by our modern day access to the entire world's knowledge - is the freeing up of the individual from the unhelpful collectives that taint and retard his or her thinking, and the bringing about of rational pursuits that stand or fall on their own empirical merits.
In
fact, I would go so far as to say that I cannot think of a single group that
has been beneficial to its members and closed itself to what is true, factual
and rational in favour of being hermetically sealed by the discourse of its
leadership.
No comments:
Post a Comment